Where Do We Stand is fighting to keep the municipal forest intact. (submitted)

Where Do We Stand is fighting to keep the municipal forest intact. (submitted)

Guest column: Public consultation: the stacked deck

It would be easy to walk away in cynicism. But we’re not. We’re sounding the alarm.

By Icel Dobell

Sadly, a citizens’ Working Group established to help guide public consultation on the future of the municipal forest reserve appears to be a rubber stamp. And the deep, broad, transparent, inclusive, accountable, unbiased process we had expected has not transpired.

It would be easy for Where Do We Stand to walk away in cynicism. But we’re not. We’re sounding the alarm.

WDWS joined the working group (WG) in good faith to contribute to a transparent engagement process. But it is being kept secret.

Several times the WG has been given instructions not to put out materials to the public. Meetings are closed and they refuse to record them for the public.

At the third WG meeting on Monday, June 6, members voted 58 per cent in favour of transparency before the public — to tape the meetings.

But virtual unanimity is required. So, citizens are left with minutes that report selectively what has transpired rather than full access to make their own judgments.

Also worrisome, the draft survey and discussion guide (DG), presented to the WG before being posted online, are biased toward the business-as-usual plantation forestry model and full of leading questions.

For instance, the draft survey asks you whether local family-supporting forestry jobs are important to you. (Note the leading “family supporting”). It’s particularly misleading because it doesn’t spell out that logging last year employed, in man hours, about 10 people, two of them staff and the two logging companies are from up-Island. The question is also silent on the greater number of jobs created by preserving the mountains for recreation and tourism, including bike shops, artisans, restaurants, pubs, bed and breakfasts, and on and on.

The draft survey asks the same about the forest reserve contributing to local mills and sawyers; (local mills and sawyers don’t get to buy our logs, according to everyone I’ve interviewed); it fails to mention 63 per cent of our trees were exported last year.

The DG says, in recent years the forest reserve earned an annual average $288,000 net profit. Fact is, since 1987, the net profit is $132,740 a year on average. Since 2017, one-third of that is renting land to a cell tower (included as forest profit!) .

The DG fails to outright report that UBC says carbon credits could generate as much or more cash than logging (selling to local buyers, not Chevron ) .

Also troubling, the consultants will allow only 5,000 words of written submissions and won’t consider the 800 citizen comments submitted with the original 1,500 person petition that began this whole process.

Who decides what comments will be prioritized? No comment.

The online platform, Placespeak, will be used despite widespread concerns it’s too confusing.

The absence of broad, deep education is another issue. People lack a thorough understanding of our forests and their ecological importance as part of the most endangered landscape in B.C. — the coastal Douglas-fir biogeoclimatic zone.

The coup de gras: the “interim plan.” Council has endorsed a two-stage consultation process. The first phase, the interim stage, is being hurried along with the apparent goal of continued logging while the second plan is developed. What is the “interim plan?” I have no idea. We have been asking for a year and haven’t received a comprehensive answer from staff and the consultants. At the recent Forest Advisory Committee meeting, the mayor said even some councillors are asking what it is.

When we ask tough questions, the consultants come back with: “council approved it.” I fear that council, too, is being used as a rubber stamp, that our elected officials want to do the right thing but are also bombarded with last-minute reports to synthesize in impossible time frames.

WDWS wanted to believe the process would be fair. We didn’t want to believe the debate is another stacked deck, an infomercial for the forestry department. Now, our only hope that consultation and the “ship” (as the municipality calls itself) could turn around is council. We are counting on the mayor and councillors, as our elected tugboats, to demand a transparent, open, inclusive, broad, deep process.

There is so much more to report. Please follow WhereDoWeStand.ca for updates.

Icel Dobell

Where Do We Stand

Letters

Just Posted

Capitals’ Kahlil Fontana blueliner evades Alberni Valley Bulldogs’ Ethan Hersant during second-period B.C. Hockey League Island Division action at the Alberni Valley Multiplex on Saturday, April 10, 2021. (Susan Quinn/Black Press Media)
Cowichan Capitals go out with a bang

Caps finish BCHL season strong with 6-1 thumping of Clippers

The MS Society flag flies at Duncan city hall to mark MS Awareness Month. (Kevin Rothbauer/Citizen)
Duncan and CVRD help mark MS Awareness Month

MS Walk scales back, but fundraisers are still vital for MS Society

“Keeping fit for Mother’s Day: Participants of Cowichan Lake Recreation’s Mother’s Day hiking event make their way down the Trans Canada Trail, Sunday, May 8. The morning event later wrapped up with snacks and prizes.” (Tyler Clarke/Lake Cowichan Gazette May 11, 2011)
Flashback: Bears, elk, salmon, candidates, and lumber graders

This week around Cowichan Lake in years gone by

Sign up to fundraise to help those affected by dementia. (Submitted)
Not too late for Cowichan residents to join Alzheimer’s Walk

Set a walking or fitness goal for May and raise funds for the Alzheimer Society of B.C.

Robert’s column
Robert Barron Column: Poachers in forest reserve should be treated harshly

‘Poachers need to be rounded up and prosecuted as soon as possible’

Daily confirmed COVID-19 cases reported to B.C. public health, seven-day rolling average in white, to May 12, 2021. (B.C. Centre for Disease Control)
B.C. preparing ‘Restart 2.0’ from COVID-19 as June approaches

Daily infections fall below 500 Friday, down to 387 in hospital

A vial of AstraZeneca vaccine is seen at a mass COVID-19 vaccination clinic in Calgary, Alta., Thursday, April 22, 2021. Dr. Ben Chan remembers hearing the preliminary reports back in March of blood clots appearing in a handful of European recipients of the Oxford-AstraZeneca COVID-19 vaccine. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jeff McIntosh
Science on COVID, VITT constantly changing: A look at how doctors keep up

While VITT can represent challenges as a novel disorder, blood clots themselves are not new

Poached trees that were taken recently on Vancouver Island in the Mount Prevost area near Cowichan, B.C. are shown on Sunday, May 10, 2021. Big trees, small trees, dead trees, softwoods and hardwoods have all become valuable targets of tree poachers in British Columbia as timber prices hit record levels. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jen Osborne.
Tree poaching from public forests increasing in B.C. as lumber hits record prices

Prices for B.C. softwood lumber reached $1,600 for 1,000 board feet compared with about $300 a year ago

The warm weather means time for a camping trip, or at least an excursion into nature. How much do you know about camps and camping-related facts? (John Arendt - Summerland Review)
QUIZ: Are you ready to go camping?

How many camp and camping-related questions can you answer?

On Friday, May 14 at Meadow Gardens Golf Club in Pitt Meadows, Michael Caan joined a very elite club of golfers who have shot under 60 (Instagram)
Crowds at English Bay were blasted with a large beam of light from an RCMP Air-1 helicopter on Friday, May 14. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Marc Grandmaison
Police enlist RCMP helicopter to disperse thousands crowded on Vancouver beach

On Friday night, police were witness to ‘several thousand people staying well into the evening’

Sinikka Gay Elliott was reported missing on Salt Spring Island on Wednesday, May 12. (Courtesty Salt Spring RCMP)
Body of UBC professor found on Salt Spring Island, no foul play suspected

Sinikka Elliott taught sociology at the university

The first Black judge named to the BC Supreme Court, Selwyn Romilly, was handcuffed at 9:15 a.m. May 14 while walking along the seawall. (YouTube/Screen grab)
Police apologize after wrongly arresting B.C.’s first Black Supreme Court Justice

At 81 years old, the retired judge was handcuffed in public while out for a walk Friday morning

Queen Elizabeth II and Clive Holland, deputy commonwealth president of the Royal Life Saving Society, top left, virtually present Dr. Steve Beerman, top right, with the King Edward VII Cup for his drowning-prevention work. Tanner Gorille and Sarah Downs were honoured with Russell Medals for their life-saving resuscitation. (Buckingham Palace photo)
Queen presents Vancouver Island doctor with award for global drowning prevention

Dr. Steve Beerman receives Royal Life Saving Society’s King Edward VII Cup at virtual ceremony

Most Read