A little more on the history of Christmas

None of that has any bearing on whether Christmas is a proper Christian holiday in its own right.

letters

A little more on the history of Christmas

Re: Historical roots of Christmas (Dec. 18)

Oh boy, where to begin with this one. There’s more misinformation than allegedly in the Fox news broadcasts Mr. Rock seems fixated on.

While there’s not really a “war on Christmas”, at least not here in the west, there has been a gradual but relatively minor pushback against it, particularly from those who believe in the nonexistent right to not be offended.

It has been argued that Christmas isn’t real because “It’s not even his birthday!” To which the reply is, “Well, we celebrate Queen Victoria’s birthday, and guess what. That’s not her actual birthday.” The comment that the Bible can’t agree on the date doesn’t even apply, because to say that implies there are multiple dates in the Bible for it, when there isn’t even one. Various scholars in antiquity have proposed various dates and several did so without any need for borrowing a Roman holiday, with the theory that if Jesus was conceived on Passover, his birth date would be on or around Dec. 25. Others have proposed Jan. 6, and the Eastern Orthodox church celebrates it on Jan. 7. None of that has any bearing on whether Christmas is a proper Christian holiday in its own right. Some have claimed Dec. 25 as birthdays for various pagan deities, but the flaw in that argument is that there are no actual recorded birthdates for them.

It’s true that many Christians warming the pews don’t have proper knowledge of what they believe. Those who are supposed to be teaching them are neglecting their duty. As to an alleged marriage of Jewish and pagan beliefs, Saint Paul did nothing of the sort. “Christian” was originally a slur directed at followers of Jesus, before Paul even took up the task of preaching in Jesus’s name. Prior to doing so, he was one of the primary persecutors of Christians. He was a Pharisee and had no interest in mixing pagan and Jewish ideals at any time.

There are scholars with no religious dog in the fight that will tell you all about how the arguments against Jesus having existed are wrong, not to mention how the argument that Jesus’ story was cribbed from pagan mythology is also incorrect. Skeptics tend to overuse Bart Ehrman but some fail to realize that he isn’t a proponent of the concept that the story of Jesus was cobbled together from various pagan myths. There are sites, such as tektonics.org, that credibly debunk many skeptical claims that Mr. Rock seems to have accepted uncritically.

Yes, Jesus was a Jew. But he also knew that people of his community would reject him and his teachings, which de facto created another religion, because he made changes they couldn’t accept for whatever reason.

If God went to Mary like Zeus did to various women, in order to impregnate her, it would literally defeat the purpose of a virgin birth. Jesus’ own disciples believed he was the son of God — but not a son of God in the way Mr. Rock thinks.

Science can’t tell us what “ought” to be. You can’t get an “ought” from an “is”.

And finally, no, Santa Claus was not created by Haddon Sundblom making an ad for the Coca-Cola company in 1930. That’s an urban legend. Thomas Nast, a civil war cartoonist, is credited for depicting what would become the modern representation of Santa Claus, but the base concept originated with Saint Nicholas, in the 4th century AD.

April J. Gibson

Duncan

Letters

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Egg producers in B.C. aren’t obligated to reveal their production sites. (Sarah Simpson/Citizen)
Not enough local eggs to meet demand: officials

BC Egg Marketing Board doesn’t regulate labelling

The new Malahat Skywalk is expected to be completed by this summer. (Submitted graphic)
Malahat Skywalk expected to be complete by this summer

$15-million project will see 650-metre elevated wooden pathway constructed

Tim Schewe
Drivesmart column: It’s the highway’s fault!

One component of Vision Zero (our current road safety strategy) is highway design.

A scene from “Canada and the Gulf War: In their own words,” a video by The Memory Project, a program of Historica Canada, is shown in this undated illustration. THE CANADIAN PRESS/HO - Historica Canada
New video marks Canada’s contributions to first Gulf War on 30th anniversary

Veterans Affairs Canada says around 4,500 Canadian military personnel served during the war

Canada released proposed regulations Jan. 2 for the fisheries minister to maintain Canada’s major fish stocks at sustainable levels and recover those at risk. (File photo)
New laws would cement DFO accountability to depleted fish stocks

Three B.C. salmon stocks first in line for priority attention under proposed regulations

Trees destroyed a Shoreacres home during a wind storm Jan. 13, 2021. Photo: Submitted
Kootenay woman flees just before tree crushes house

Pamala DeRosa is thankful to be alive

Gin, one of the Kantymirs’ two sheep. (Martha Wickett-Salmon Arm Observer)
Sheep start up ATV, sit in cars and go for walks in Salmon Arm

Until they bought two sheep, Ken and Karleen Kantymir didin’t realize just how social the animals are

Heather Lucier, a pastor at Kelowna Harvest Fellowship, speaks to an RCMP officer outside of Harvest Ministries on Sunday, Jan. 10. (Michael Rodriguez - Capital News)
Kelowna church fined 2nd time for violating public health order

Harvest Ministries in Kelowna has previously said they will fight the tickets in court

Emma Nunn from Alberni Valley Rescue Squad waits at the summit of Mount Arrowsmith for the rest of the AVRS rope rescue team on Sunday, Jan. 17, 2021. (PHOTO COURTESY DAVE POULSEN, AVRS)
UPDATE: Injured hiker among three rescued in the dark from Mount Arrowsmith

‘It was a very bad, very precarious spot to be able to locate them’

Powell River-Sunshine Coast MLA Nicholas Simons was appointed to the NDP cabinet as minister of social development and poverty reduction after the October 2020 B.C. election. (Hansard TV)
B.C. job training fund increased for developmentally disabled

COVID-19 has affected 1,100 ‘precariously employed’ people

A Sooke woman is speaking up after she was almost tricked by a lottery scam, claiming she had won $950,000 with Set for Life Lottery. (File Photo)
‘I wanted it to be true so badly’: Sooke senior narrowly avoids lottery scam

88-year-old received letter stating she had won $950,000

B.C. driver’s licence and identity cards incorporate medical services, but the passport option for land crossings is being phased out. (B.C. government)
B.C. abandons border ID cards built into driver’s licence

$35 option costing ICBC millions as demand dwindles

Most Read