Saying of dubious provenance, use

There are several variants, all of dubious provenance

Saying of dubious provenance, use

Re: “Will we only realize what we’ve done when too late?”, (Citizen, Nov. 22)

The writer cites an anachronistic “Old Cree saying” which is almost certainly not an old Cree saying, unless your idea of old sayings is 40 years ago, give or take a few years.

It’s impossible to determine if the person who invented it was actually Cree, but it’s likely they were not. There are several variants, all of dubious provenance; but the most common one differs from the one published: “When the last tree has been cut down, when the last fish has been caught, only then will we realize we cannot eat money”.

“Poisoned rivers” was almost certainly added by Greenpeace, as it doesn’t appear in the earliest known citations. Overfishing is a legitimate concern, but cutting down trees clears land that can be used for farms — resulting in the opposite of having nothing to eat but currency. So, the next time you run into a pithy old saying, question it. There are better ways to motivate people than tricky phrases and thought-terminating cliches.

April J. Gibson

Duncan

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Cowichan Performing Arts Centre streaming new short film tonight

Standing By has been created and performed by Cowichan-raised actor Nicole Ratjen.

Original drums recovered amid offers to replace stolen Chemainus church set

Chemainus United Church grateful for actions of a caring community

Who’s running in Cowichan?

A list of Cowichan candidates for the upcoming provincial election

Shawnigan Lake’s Kubica gets 25 to life for murder in California

Former Shawnigan Lake man convicted of killing woman in 1990

Police seek help in naming Cowichan farmstand theft suspect

Video captured man prying cash box out stand on Norcross Road

B.C.’s top doctor encourages Halloween costumes to include masks

Dr. Bonnie Henry will soon be releasing guidelines on how to safely trick-or-treat this Halloween

Shoplifting suspect allegedly spits on worker at store in Nanaimo

Suspect became aggressive when confronted by loss prevention officer at Walmart, say RCMP

Reincarnation, baby! Music-making B.C. couple celebrate ‘miracle’ pregnancy

‘I (said) to Adam, ‘I really think this is your brother reincarnated,’ Elise Estrada says

Survey finds doctors worry supplies of flu vaccine, PPE will lag demand

Canadian health officials have said additional flu vaccines have been ordered to meet expected demand

Search suspended for Indigenous elder last seen mushroom picking in northwest B.C.

Mushroom picker Thomas (Tommy) Dennis has been missing since Sept. 16

Join Black Press Media and Do Some Good

Pay it Forward program supports local businesses in their community giving

Ahead of likely second wave, 60% of Canadians relaxing COVID-19 measures

Proportion of Canadians following safety measures has dropped by 3 per cent in the past two weeks

Canada’s population tops 38 million, even as COVID-19 pandemic slows growth

Immigration, the top population driver, decreased due to the pandemic

Lightning strike: Tampa Bay blanks Dallas 2-0 to win Stanley Cup

Hedman wins Conn Smythe Trophy as playoff MVP

Most Read