Lawsuit may not be the next step in VIMC vs. North Cowichan spat

VIMC/GAIN will have their solicitors ask for a “writ of Mandamus”

Lawsuit may not be the next step in VIMC vs. North Cowichan spat

Regarding the VIMC (Vancouver Island Motorsport Circuit) and the MNC (Municipality of North Cowichan) ongoing debate/issue…

Sooo…I have sequestered my comment on the VIMC epic battle, standing on the sidelines, watching the saga unfold. Soap opera in nature and character(s) as it is. But on certain matters I sense it is time to now say what needs saying.

That said, confusion reigns on the ground about just what the legalities and their natures that are before one and all may well be — that is, as I see it, as I know it. Basically, a lack of knowledge and understandings by the common folk of what “off to the courts” may entail seems to be the soup of the day. Could be wrong here, but I do think not.

My points(s), as Yogi Berra said, “when you come to a fork in the road take it”! And we certainly have, a resumed public hearing with an enhanced platter of amenities, before a court of public opinion, and a looming court of law engagement, before the B.C. Supreme Court judiciary.

I would like to pause and emphasize that MNC has a very high end counsel with Lawyer Sukh Manhas giving them guidance. Manhas is among a handful of recognized authorities in B.C. on municipal structure and related law. His equal peers are not that many. Just for everyone’s comfort, MNC is well counselled.

Wandering into speculation, at my own peril, I would not be surprised if VIMC/GAIN were to abandon the rezoning effort before the next resumption of public hearing. Just saying. But if not, if the MNC denies the rezoning, after further public hearings, then the other fork in the road is imminent. And here the confusion emerges.

All the dialogue I hear and see is about a $60 million lawsuit possibility of being brought by VIMC/GAIN for indemnity and damages, against MNC.

That is not what will happen, at least not first off. VIMC/GAIN will have their solicitors ask for a “writ of Mandamus”, an order from the courts directing MNC to issue the requested development permit, and IMHO they are likely, or most probable to get such a Mandamus. That is, if VIMC/GAIN can first establish that the I2 zoning is to their favour, as MNC has stated, in written form a couple of times now.

How so? Why so? Good question. And here I wander far past my expertise, but someone needs to say something on just what’s actually happening, or most probably going to happen.

First on this matter, precedent, case law mined from across Canada, is pertinent and applicable, much of it historic, but as well recent and emerging judgements.

VIMC will rest their pleadings for a writ of Mandamus upon past law precedent(s) (and that could be many) as there are many in case law.

I will list two that I know are of consequence, and IMHO and experiences, most applicable, and most likely to be referenced. That is because both resulted in Mandamus being given.

One, is Rocky Point Metalcraft v. Cowichan Valley Regional District, (Part 1 and Part 2), a judgement built substantially upon the precedent of Yearsley v. White Rock (City of), 2009 BCSC 719.

Much about the ultimate order of Mandamus given in favour of Yearsley(s) is similar in many manners to the VIMC-MNC development permit scenario, in my layperson’s judgement. I encourage you to Google and read the judgements for yourself.

There, that said. And without prejudice. Google: “writ of Mandamus”

Yearsley v. White Rock(City of) 2009 BCSC 719

https://www.canlii.org/en/bc/bcsc/doc/2009/2009bcsc719/2009bcsc719.html

Rocky Point Metalcraft v. Cowichan Valley Regional District

2011 BCSC 441 (Part1)

https://www.canlii.org/en/bc/bcsc/doc/2011/2011bcsc441/2011bcsc441.html

Rocky Point Metalcraft v. Cowichan Valley Regional District

2012 BCSC 756 (Part 2)

https://www.canlii.org/en/bc/bcsc/doc/2012/2012bcsc756/2012bcsc756.html

Loren Duncan

Sahtlam

Just Posted

Lexi Bainas column: Music, miniature masterpieces, and a long-lost banjo

Some truly heartwarming news last week: Chuck McCandless has his banjo back!

What you said: the solutions to the Highway 18 elk situation are varied

Is it the speed of drivers, the at-times-blind corners, or the poor lighting?

Cowichan Valley farmers argue for repeal of Bill 52

Limits on farm dwellings, other issue, raise concerns

Cowichan School District’s ‘Hello Dolly’ offers space for cultural questions

SD79 presents bi-weekly video series with Cowichan Elder

VIDEO: Kenney lays out key demands for meeting with Trudeau

Alberta Premier Jason Kenney aims for clear signs of federal action on two-day Ottawa trip

Province sues over sailing incident that killed teen with disabilities

Gabriel Pollard, 16, died from injuries after marine lift failed

First Nations want Big Bar landslide cleared ASAP to allow fish passage

Leadership calling for urgent action and resources to remove obstruction on the Fraser

Assessed value of Lower Mainland homes expected to decrease in 2020

Other areas of province may see modest increases over last year’s values

Chilliwack family’s therapy dog injured in hit and run

Miniature pit bull Fifty’s owner is a single mother facing close to $10,000 in vet bills

Cougar destroyed in Penticton area after mauling dog, killing cat

This is the first reported incident with a cougar this year in the Penticton area

Feds not enforcing standards on Hungarian duck imports, B.C. farmer says

‘You have no way of knowing what’s in the bag’

No reports yet of Canadians affected by New Zealand volcano eruption, feds say

Missing and injured included tourists from the U.S., China, Australia, Britain and Malaysia

Vancouver Island blues musician’s mother’s home burglarized and ransacked

David Gogo’s 71-year-old mother has jewelry and artwork stolen in break-in

Most Read