Judge’s decision in bizarre fight case naive

This case was an example of the serious flaws in our legal system.

Judge’s decision in bizarre fight case naive

Re: “One of four charges sticks in bizarre fight”, (Citizen, Dec. 1)

This case was an example of the serious flaws in our legal system.

Judge J.P. MacCarthy’s decision seems naive in the extreme, given the evidence — that Whitehead was treated in hospital for the blow to his ribs and suffered a smashed hearing aid. What was missing from the story was the large age discrepancy (Whitehead is in his 70s) between the two men.

Whitehead is a highly respected environmentalist in the Cowichan Valley and beyond who does talks and leads tours for Elder College. The judge failed to apply the simplest logic in the case and the Crown failed to challenge the accused’s story in any way. We are all in deep trouble if a simple assault charge can’t be upheld, and will have to fend for ourselves rather than assume the legal system will protect us.

What is even worse is that the Cowichan Citizen missed an opportunity to ask a few more questions (or even add the ages of the two men). Disappointing all around.

Susan Down

Duncan

Just Posted

Over-30 Cowichan Cougars edged by Vic West

Early goal proves insurmountable

Demolition of derelict buildings begins in Lake Cowichan

It’s taken a long time to accomplish but demolition is underway or finished at several sites

VIDEO: This is what buying legal pot in B.C. looks like

Take a look inside B.C.’s first and only legal pot shop located in Kamloops

Cowichan Red Arrow plays to Div. 4 soccer draw

Red Arrow remains among top teams in Div. 4

VIDEO: Huge 1,300-pound pumpkin take first place Old Farm Market weigh off

Blessed by a sunny day, the contest draws pumpkins from the Island, mainland, and the U.S.

Mellow opening to B.C.’s only legal pot shop

About five people lined up early for the opening of the BC Cannabis Store in Kamloops.

Caregivers banned from smoking, growing cannabis around children-in-care: MCFD

Ministry has limited cannabis use for caregivers, stating it may “pose a risk to children and youth.”

Cheaper strains sell out within minutes on online BC Cannabis Store

Province says new strains will become available in the coming months

Only 40% of B.C. car dealerships have electric cars available: report

Researchers found buyers frustrated at the lack of options

VIDEO: Millionaire Lottery returns to give back and win big

Since 1996, Millionaire Lottery has raised $52 million for the VGH+UBC Hospital Foundation

Test case challenges a politician’s right to block people from Twitter account

3 people say Watson infringed their constitutional right to freedom of expression by blocking them

‘A little odd’ B.C.’s biggest city celebrates cannabis without a legal store

On the streets of downtown Vancouver, notably the Wild West of illegal marijuana, not a single legal store opened Wednesday, making for a rather anticlimatic kick-off

BC Ferries begins taking debit in two-month pilot project

Company is giving customers option to use Interac on two-month trial on select vessels

Puff, puff, pass: Cannabis is officially legal across Canada

B.C. has only one bricks-and-mortar marijuana store

Most Read