Judge’s decision in bizarre fight case naive

This case was an example of the serious flaws in our legal system.

Judge’s decision in bizarre fight case naive

Re: “One of four charges sticks in bizarre fight”, (Citizen, Dec. 1)

This case was an example of the serious flaws in our legal system.

Judge J.P. MacCarthy’s decision seems naive in the extreme, given the evidence — that Whitehead was treated in hospital for the blow to his ribs and suffered a smashed hearing aid. What was missing from the story was the large age discrepancy (Whitehead is in his 70s) between the two men.

Whitehead is a highly respected environmentalist in the Cowichan Valley and beyond who does talks and leads tours for Elder College. The judge failed to apply the simplest logic in the case and the Crown failed to challenge the accused’s story in any way. We are all in deep trouble if a simple assault charge can’t be upheld, and will have to fend for ourselves rather than assume the legal system will protect us.

What is even worse is that the Cowichan Citizen missed an opportunity to ask a few more questions (or even add the ages of the two men). Disappointing all around.

Susan Down

Duncan

Just Posted

Cowichan transgender woman hosting Gender Identity Expression Day

“We need to have a public conversation about this.”

Andrea Rondeau column: Chemainus Theatre Festival a unique, surprising venue

Not many towns the size of Chemainus can boast a year-round professional theatre

Sarah Simpson Column: Perfect road trip features flat tire and lost wallet

My husband is a loser. Not a loser in the dead-beat, good-for-nothin’… Continue reading

Are you 55 or older? Try 5 sports for free

June 5 event promotes BC 55+ Games and active living

Outlaws make statement in first spring hockey tourney

2011 team takes bronze in brilliant debut

VIDEO: Protesters in Penticton gather to rally against sleeping-on-sidewalk bylaw

The proposed bylaw would outlaw sitting or lying on the city’s downtown sidewalks

Coming up in Cowichan: From bike rodeo to ‘A Word About Consent’, lots on the calendar

Christian Science event coming to Duncan Saturday, May 25 “Breaking News: Freedom… Continue reading

Kamloops girl, 9, recovering from carbon monoxide poisoning now out of ICU

Her mother who was sleeping in the same tent with her did not survive

‘I think he’s still alive’: B.C. mom pleads for help finding son last seen a month ago

Family offering $5,000 reward for information leading to the safe return of Tim Delahaye

New poll suggests one-third don’t want politicians to wear religious symbols

Local politicians shouldn’t be allowed to wear hijabs, crucifixes or turbans on the job, survey suggests

Raptors fans far from home adjust plans to watch pivotal playoff game

Raptors currently lead the playoff series 3-2, and a win Saturday would vault them into NBA finals

PHOTOS: First responders in Fernie rescue baby owl who fell from nest

The baby owl’s inability to fly back to its nest prompted a rescue by first responders

Five takeaways from the Court of Appeal ruling on B.C.’s pipeline law

It’s unclear how many tools are left in B.C.’s toolbox to fight the project

Most Read