Cowichan Lake weir expert Craig Sutherland talks about the rule band and the rule curve approaches to operating the weir during a Cowichan Watershed Board meeting at the Cowichan Lake Education Centre

Raising the weir would increase erosion on Cowichan Lake

It’s well-known in the Cowichan Lake area that it’s hard to keep a conversation moving once the idea of raising the Cowichan Lake weir is mentioned.

  • Apr. 11, 2011 1:00 p.m.

It’s well-known in the Cowichan Lake area that it’s hard to keep a conversation moving once the idea of raising the Cowichan Lake weir is mentioned.

This was the case during a Cowichan Watershed Board public meeting at the Cowichan Lake Education Centre, Thursday, April 7.

During the event’s first presentation, by erosion specialist Eric Morris, the presenter made mention of raising the weir in relation to the effect it would have on overall erosion.

“If you change the water level you’re going to change the mean shoreline and shift it,” he said, adding that erosion will take place in order to establish a new equilibrium.

“The weir raising is relatively small to the existing weir, but there will be some re-shaping to the shoreline.”

Overall, raising the weir would have a small impact upon the shoreline compared to some other factors.

During his presentation, Morris revealed that he had travelled around the entire Cowichan Lake shoreline in September, when water is the lowest.

In his travels and research, Morris concluded that Honeymoon Bay and  Youbou shoreline erosion is mainly the fault of residents who have built seawalls (rocks or cement on the shore to prevent erosion at that location) and groynes (docks or barriers pointing out into the lake; also to prevent erosion at a particular location).

“Erosion occurs when sediment budget is not balanced,” he explained. “A sea wall will disturb the cross-wall transport.”

A groyne may prevent erosion on one side, but that side will also collect more sediment, while the other erodes away.

Log boom removal has also resulted in erosion in the Honeymoon Bay area.

Second-most at fault for erosion in Honeymoon Bay, and Youbou, and tied with most to blame for erosion at Gordon Bay Provincial Park and Spring Beach, is vegetation removal, followed by vessel traffic.

Although the Cowichan Lake weir is in most locations the least to blame for erosion, a comment from the audience following Morris’s presentation was that the weir shouldn’t be fussed with. Taking into account all of these other things that are eroding the shoreline, adding the raising of the weir into the mix – a factor that we can control – is asking for trouble.

“I agree,” Morris said. “It’s a fair comment.”

If the weir were to be raised, Morris suggested that monitoring stations be put in place to measure the weir’s effect.

But, why was the raising of the weir even being discussed, with such a strong opposition from members of the public who attended the meeting?

It’s because of the users downstream, Watershed Board representative Rodger Hunter explained. They need water downstream, and local sewage systems require at least seven cubic meters per second of flow from the Cowichan Lake into the Cowichan River to properly dilute their runoff.

“It needs that dilution flow to meet their target when it comes to that pollution level,” presenter and weir expert Craig Sutherland said during his presentation, later on in the meeting.

Since 1984, inflows into Cowichan Lake have reduced by 30 per cent.

“The inflows over the last decade have gone even lower,” Hunter said. “Things are changing, so we can’t stick to historical levels.”

A while back, the idea of raising the weir was deferred until a number of tests had taken place, of which the erosion study Morris has recently completed is but one.

“Any weir change would require further study,” Hunter explained. “That’s a ways off.”

Sutherland’s presentation on the weir’s rule band/rule curve approach to managing summer water levels, came next.

Throughout the summer, the Cowichan Lake weir ramps down its control gates in order to ensure the Cowichan River has enough water flowing into it for the dry summer. This is the rule curve approach, wherein the weir is lowered at a steady rate to allow a required minimum flow of seven cubic meters per second, treating Cowichan Lake like a bathtub.

Without having to raise the top of the weir, the rule band approach is similar to the rule curve approach of ramping down the weir, but provides more flexibility throughout the year, with a larger range with which the weir can be raised or lowered within its current range.

“Providing that extra little bit of storage gives us a little bit more assurance,” he said.

The weir remains off-control throughout the winter, as during this time of year there is plenty of precipitation to fill both the Cowichan Lake and River.

Typically, the weir is put back on control by the beginning of April, but Sutherland said that this has been postponed due to a particularly wet spring.

Following a couple more presentations, including one on the Cowichan Watershed Board’s many broad future goals, the meeting came to a close.

The group’s next meeting will take place Thursday, May 5, in either North Cowichan or Duncan.

As the location and time is finalized, it will be posted online, at www.cowichanwatershedboard.ca.

Just Posted

Teamwork and rotating 12 hour shifts helped Island Health weather the storm in Cowichan

“At one time we had 11 hospital sites on generator power”

Cowichan’s private seniors care facilities used generators to get through outage

Like so many places, the power went out at 11:30 a.m. Thursday,… Continue reading

Fences destroyed, power out but Cowichan’s animals were safe after epic Dec. 20 storm

“It was a wake up call for being prepared for emergencies.”

B.C. storm totals $37M in insured damages

The December storm wreaked havoc on B.C.’s south coast

North Cowichan will host new permanent rowing centre starting October 2020

Saanich’s bid for national rowing centre at Elk Lake sunk

VIDEO: Cowichan Secondary starts two-week run of ‘The Addams Family’ Jan. 16

The Cow High cast is ready, the stage is set: all they need is you so make tracks to see this show

Chiasson nets shootout winner as Oilers edge Canucks 3-2

Edmonton moves one point ahead of Vancouver

B.C. chief says they didn’t give up rights for gas pipeline to be built

Hereditary chief: no elected band council or Crown authority has jurisdiction over Wet’suwet’en land

Thieves steal thousands from 140 Coast Capital Savings members

Online fraud tactics included phising and ‘brute force’ in November and December

Condo rental bans may be on way out with B.C. empty home tax

Many exemptions to tax, but annual declarations required

UPDATE: B.C. boy, aunt missing for three days

The pair are missing from Kamloops

Daredevil changes game plan to jump broken White Rock pier

Brooke Colby tells council daredevil event would help boost waterfront business

Liberal bows out of byelection after singling out Jagmeet Singh’s race

Karen Wang says she made comments online that referenced Singh’s cultural background

Most Read